(Assigment) Critique Challenge

The chosen animation for this aesthetic evaluation is Larva. One criteria has been set based on relativisme.  i.e, the criteria is nationalism, love, helping and lastly beauty. For nationalism, audience must have a higher spirit of nationalism when watching finish the video of the animation.  For beauty, audience must feel like to watching the video of the animation if the character design is very attractive. The third criteria is helping. Audience will helping each other with sincerity after finish watching the video of the animation. And the last of criteria is love. Audience will love and have desire to love others when finished watching the video of the animation.

I choose Larva animation to make an evaluation. In this animation, spirit nationalism not in this story, and no impact on the audience. For me, to raise the spirit of nationalism to the audience is, the director Should add nationalism scene. In this animation, I think, the nature of helping each other not in this story, and viewers can not follow suit. For me, to be a good example in this story, director need to enter the scene where the larva must have the nature of helping each other. What I like in this story is that this story has feeling love with each other. This can be a role model to every audience. This criteria is also the criteria I want in each story. character design I've seen in this story is very interesting. This may attract the audience to watch.

My friend has been set their own criteria. First, Noor Baizura has set four criteria, there is smile, sadly, loving and friendly.  Hazleen Anylia has set crying, sympathy, laugh and happy. Then, Dalila Sha’irah has set the criteria is logical thinking, understand, moral value and the last criteria is happy ending. Among my friend, there is similarity with my friends, Noor Baizura. The criteria is loving. What I can see in this discussion, everyone have their own perception about how to evaluate the animation. Different people, have a different opinion. For example, we choose the same animation, the animation is Larva, but we have choose different criteria to evaluate the video. It we can see in this discussion, we have been take decision that, we take the best two criteria from each other. The criteria that we choose is appropriate with the evaluation concept. The criteria from Noor Baizura is friendly and loving. Second is Hazleen Anylia sympathy and happy. Criteria from Dalila sha’irah is logical thinking and moral value and from myself, I choose criteria is beauty and nationalism. This criteria, we use to evaluate the Larva.

                Conclusion about the evaluation concept, there is four. Subjectivism, objectivism, relativism and emotivism. From this, everyone choose one and after that, we set the criteria.  Everyone have their own criteria to evaluate the animation. Lastly, we decide to choose eight the best criteria. We hope criteria will help us to evaluate the animation. No one can say no to take criteria that we chosen because everybody have their own opinion and perception.